PostEngage vs SuperProfile

SuperProfile is where the sale happens. We are what talks before it.

If you sell from your bio you may already have a SuperProfile link there, and AutoDM came free with it. So the only honest question on this page is what a second tool could possibly add, and the answer is one thing, not ten.

Start freeSee pricingFree forever, no card.

Where SuperProfile wins

SuperProfile is the better buy the moment money has to change hands. Their plans carry a link-in-bio store, digital products, courses, bookings, events and lead magnets with, as their pricing page put it on 21 October 2026, no commission fee on what you earn. Creator also lists AI replies, comment moderation and an Instagram and Facebook scheduler. We sell nothing, host nothing and take no payments, so a creator who needs one place to be paid should stay exactly where they are.

Where PostEngage wins

Instagram only, done carefully. Templated replies are free and unlimited, and you pay one credit per AI reply in your voice. Every reply passes sixteen safety checks first.

Side by side

Starting price
SuperProfile$4.99 first month, then $29/moPostEngageLite $4/mo (₹149), unlimited DMs
Free plan
SuperProfileStore, AutoDMs on Reels and posts, 10 leadsPostEngageUnlimited comment replies, 1,000 DMs every 30 days, 100 AI credits once
What you pay for
SuperProfileA flat plan, 0% commission on salesPostEngageAI-written replies; nothing per contact
AI replies
SuperProfileListed on CreatorPostEngageIn your voice; 3,000/mo on Creator, $12 (₹899)
Accounts included
SuperProfileUp to 5 Instagram accounts on CreatorPostEngage1 on Free and Lite, 2 on Creator, 5 on Studio
Store and payments
SuperProfileProducts, courses, bookings, eventsPostEngageNone. We are not in the payment path
Held replies
SuperProfileNot described on their pricing pagePostEngageSixteen checks before every reply, reasons shown

Read from superprofile.bio/pricing on .

We make one of these, so read this the way you would read anything written by an interested party. Every claim about the other product below comes from SuperProfile's own pages — the pricing page checked on 21 October 2026, the help centre on 24 September 2026 — and the first section is the one where we lose.

They are a business. We are a feature.

SuperProfile's pricing page, read on 21 October 2026, sells a creator's whole commercial stack: a link-in-bio store, digital products, courses, bookings, events, lead magnets, and monetisation apps around them. Starter is free forever. Creator was shown at $4.99 for the first month, renewing at $29 a month. Pro is a call with their team. The same page says no commission fee is charged on what you earn, and Creator also lists AI replies, comment moderation and an Instagram and Facebook scheduler.

That is not a competitor to us. That is the shop. We do not host a course, do not take a payment, do not issue an invoice to your buyer, and have no intention of doing any of it.

On their pricing page, not on ours

Link-in-bio store. Digital products, courses, bookings, events. Lead magnets. Up to five Instagram accounts on Creator, with AI replies, comment moderation and an Instagram and Facebook scheduler. Custom landing pages, a growth manager and an ads manager on Pro. Payments, with no commission taken.

All we do

Instagram comments and DMs through the official Graph API. No store, no checkout, no course, no link-in-bio page, no payouts, and no second channel of any kind.

If you are choosing where to be paid, this page is over and the answer is theirs.

The overlap is one feature wide

AutoDM. Their help centre, read on 24 September 2026, documents it plainly, and it is a real product: you pick any post, a specific post or your next post; you trigger on any comment or on keywords, with excluded keywords to hold it back; you write the DM; you add a button pointing at a link or at one of your SuperProfile products; and you can ask the person to follow first, or collect an email, before the main message goes out. Their pricing page lists AutoDMs as unlimited, on the free plan for Reels and posts, and across stories, DMs and lives on Creator, where AI replies are listed as well.

Ours does the same job for keywords — comment replies free and unlimited on every plan, DMs free up to 1,000 every rolling 30 days and unlimited on Lite at $4 a month (₹149). Where the two products separate is the comment that is not a keyword, and what you can read afterwards about a reply that did not go out.

AutoDM on SuperProfilePostEngage
What it is part ofA store, courses and paymentsNothing. Replies only
Keyword repliesUnlimited, per their pricing pageComments unlimited forever; DMs free to 1,000/30 days on Free, unlimited on Lite+
A question your keywords missAI replies listed on Creator; how they are written is not on the pageWritten in your voice, one credit
What is meteredThe plan, not the messagesOnly replies the model writes
Takes a cut of a saleNo commission fee, per their pageWe are not in the payment path
Why a send did not happenNot documented on the pages we readSixteen named checks, reason recorded
Their column is from superprofile.bio/pricing, checked on 21 October 2026, and the SuperProfile help centre, read on 24 September 2026. If a row is out of date, theirs is the page that decides it, not ours.

Note the fifth row. We are not claiming they charge a commission — their own page says the opposite — and the sixth row says what we read, not what they lack.

What one credit actually buys

Under a Reel that travels, the comments are not tidy. "price?", "kitne ka hai", "does this work for beginners", "bhai iska demo hai kya". A keyword list catches the first two if you wrote them down. With keyword AutoDM alone, the rest arrive as a person waiting, and your options are a message that does not answer them or silence.

That is the whole product here. A reply is drafted against a voice profile built from replies you actually wrote, so it reads like you and not like a chatbot. If the model is unsure, slow, or produces something ungrounded, your own template goes out instead. The generated reply is the upgrade, never the default.

A diagram separating templated replies, which are free, from AI-written replies, which spend one credit each
Everything on the free side of this line is the part AutoDM already does for you. We charge for the other side.

Before any of it sends, sixteen checks run in a fixed order — kill switch, connection, takeover, auto-reply switch, complaint pause, window, dedupe, burst, bot loop, cooldown, quiet hours, account limits, rate budget, free DM cap, credits, content safety. The first failure stops the send and writes down why, so a reply that did not go out is something you can read afterwards instead of a mystery. Takeover is the one creators notice: press Take over in Inbox, or reply from Inbox, and automation stands down on that thread. Replying in the Instagram app does not pause it.

Neither of us can outrun Meta

Both products sit on the official Instagram API, so both live in the same box: a DM can be sent within 24 hours of that person's last message, a comment answered within 7 days. Nobody sells an exemption, and a tool that implies otherwise is not describing the official API. The shape of it is set out in is Instagram DM automation safe.

Their pricing page shows dollars, and so does ours: Lite is $4 a month and Creator $12, with rupee prices for India (₹149 and ₹899). The India arithmetic is in the cheapest way to automate Instagram DMs in India.

What setting it up looks like

Five screens, and the first live reply usually happens inside fifteen minutes. Nothing here replaces your SuperProfile store; it sits beside it.

  1. 01

    Connect Instagram

    Three permissions — read comments, reply to them, send the DM you wrote. Meta runs the login, so no password reaches us, and disconnecting is on the same screen.

  2. 02

    Write the trigger

    Any post, a specific post or your next post, then the words people actually type. Matching ignores case and punctuation, and a negative keyword holds the reply back.

  3. 03

    Write both replies

    A public reply that keeps the post moving and a private reply that carries the link — which can point straight at your SuperProfile product page.

  4. 04

    Try it, then go live

    Try it takes a pretend comment, runs every check against the live account and shows the replies exactly as they would go out. Nothing is sent, and nothing reaches a follower until you press Go live.

  5. 05

    Read Activity in week one

    Every send and every refusal with a reason, so a reply that never went out is a line you can read rather than a mystery.

The PostEngage connect screen with the Connect Instagram button and the permission list annotated
Step one, annotated: three scopes, listed in plain English before you approve them, and no password anywhere in the flow.

How to test this without moving anything

Checklist

If the answer is zero, you have learnt something useful for free and SuperProfile was always enough. If the answer is a third of them, that third is the part of your inbox nobody was answering before.

The free tier here is 100 credits with no card, the full price list is on pricing, and the closest comparison to read next is ReplyKaro, who are cheaper than us and say so. If the tool you are really weighing is ManyChat, that case is on the ManyChat alternative page.

Compared with the others

Questions people ask

Does SuperProfile already do Instagram automation?
Yes, and it is not a stub. Their pricing page on 21 October 2026 lists unlimited AutoDMs on Reels and posts on the free Starter plan, and AutoDMs across Reels, posts, stories, DMs and lives on the Creator plan, along with AI replies and comment moderation. Their help centre, read on 24 September 2026, documents the builder in detail: any post, a specific post or your next post, any comment or specific keywords, excluded keywords, a message you write, a button, an optional ask-to-follow step and optional email collection.
So why would a SuperProfile creator add PostEngage on top?
One reason only: what the message says when the comment is not the one you planned for. AutoDM sends the text you wrote to the keyword you chose, and their Creator plan now lists AI replies too, without saying on the pricing page how those are written or what stops one from sending. We send your templates — comment replies free and unlimited, DMs free up to Free's 1,000-every-30-days cap and unlimited on Lite at $4 a month (₹149) — and write an answer in your own voice, learned from your past replies, when somebody asks something your templates do not cover. If every question under your Reels is already a keyword, adding us is a cost with no return and you should not.
What does SuperProfile cost?
Read from their pricing page on 21 October 2026: Starter is free forever, Creator was shown at $4.99 for the first month and $29 a month afterwards, and Pro is a conversation with their team. The same page states no platform fee on your earnings. Prices move, so open the page yourself before you decide anything on ours.
Can I run both on the same Instagram account?
Yes, if you keep the surfaces apart. Point one tool at comments on Reels and the other at story replies or incoming DMs, otherwise the same person gets two answers to one question and both tools look broken. Running us on one surface for a fortnight is the cheapest way to find out whether the writing is worth anything to you.
Do you take a cut of my sales like a store does?
We cannot, because we are not in the payment path at all. There is no store, no checkout, no course hosting and no payout on our side. Money reaches you through whatever you already use, SuperProfile included, and we never see it. What we charge is a credit when the model writes a reply, and nothing when it does not.

Answer your next comment in 5 seconds.

Free forever. No card. Three minutes to set up.

Start free